Sunday, March 19, 2017

First chance for Rabindra Mishra to show that he is different.

The Context:

I saw this post in the official page of Rabindra Mishra.

एउटा आधारहीन आरोपको खण्डन
(श्यर गरिदिनु भए आभारी हुने थिएँ)
सबभन्दा पहिले यसो भनुँ: विद्यावारिधि गर्नु, विश्वविद्यालयको प्राध्यापक हुनु भनेको, तथ्यको सुक्ष्म र प्राज्ञिक विश्लेषण गर्ने क्षमतामा विशिष्टता हासिल गर्नु हो।

तर दुखपूर्वक भन्नु पर्छ एकजना ‘प्राध्यापक-डाक्टर’ले एउटा टेलिभिजन अन्तर्वार्तामा ममाथि अत्यन्तै आधारहीन र अ-प्राज्ञिक टिप्पणी गरेछन्। आफ्ना विद्यार्थीलाई असल र विशिष्ट प्राज्ञिक संस्कारबाट दीक्षित गर्नु पर्ने व्यक्तिले त्यसप्रकारको सस्तो र चरित्रहत्या हुने टिप्पणी गर्नु दुर्भाग्यपूर्ण कुरा हो।
र, पत्रकारहरूले पनि कुनै अन्तर्वार्ता दिने व्यक्तिले कसैको गम्भिर चरित्रहत्या हुने आरोप लगाएको छ भने “अन्तर्वार्ता दिने व्यक्तिले भनेको त हो नि, मैले भनेको होइन” भनेर त्यसलाई प्रसारण/प्रकाशन गर्नु हुँदैन। लाइभ अन्तर्वार्ता हो भने अन्तर्वार्ता दिने व्यक्तिलाई तुरुन्तै रोक्नु र चुनौति दिनु पर्छ। रिकर्डेड हो भने त्यस्तो अंश सम्पादन गर्नु पर्छ या त्यसको पुष्टी गर्नै पर्छ।
नत्र अन्तर्वार्ता दिने मात्र होइन, अन्तर्वार्ता लिने व्यक्ति पनि दोषको त्यत्तिकै भागेदार हुन जान्छ।

Out of curiosity, I decided to dig deeper to understand what was going on. Then read this, "A veteran political commentator in Nepal has questioned former BBC employee Rabindra Mishra’s moral ground for leading a political party in his native Nepal. Because, Professor Surendra KC argued, Mr. Mishra once ran a media “campaign”, “within the last fifteen years”, during which interviewees were asked if Nepal should be merged into India." http://www.southasia.com.au/2017/03/19/grave-accusation-made-former-bbc-nepali-editor-turned-politician-rabindra-mishra/

My understanding of entire story: A highly regarded political commentator (Professor Surendra KC) made some serious allegations against Mr. Rabindra Mishra in a television interview. Mr. Rabindra Mishra clearly thinks the statement aims at "character defamation" and is a baseless allegation.

Some of my personal observations on the matter:

i) People making baseless statements against leaders and public figures is not a new thing. However, the way leader/public figure reacts to this allegation means a lot. The reaction shows the character of the person and tests his belief. To be honest, I am very disappointed with the facebook post of Mr. Mishra. I expected (and still expect more from him) he would clearly indicate the details of the event and the person responsible. The facebook post is a half-hearted reaction which is not a desirable trait in a leader. I do not want Mr. Mishra to get personal but he can always be clear and specific in issue this serious.

ii) If the allegation is baseless and false Mr. Rabindra Mishra should file a lawsuit against the one who made such allegation and the media house who broadcasted the interview. I am not suggesting this as personal vendetta but this in large would reflect that Mr. Mishra believes in the legal remedies (where necessary). There are other implication if the case is registered;

a) The court would find if the one making comment is guilty of defamation of a public figure, who now leads a political party. 

b) The tendency of making baseless comments without concern for legal consequences will eventually decrease. This case could set a precedent and warn those who make baseless and derogatory comments. Maybe it's time we seek accountability for the remarks one makes. 

c) The case will raise the issue of professionalism in journalism. We have seen media fail time and again but have escaped consequence for their involvement in the matter. Maybe this is time to set record straight and tell media that they too are not immune for their involvement in wrongdoing. 

d) This will set an example regarding the respect of individual while exercising one's freedom of expression. As this involves a public figure who have shown political ambition, this case will take its pace and have a social impact too. 

e) By taking legal action, Mr. Mishra can show "he indeed is different". 

Dear Rabindra Mishra Sir, You have sacrificed your glittering professional career to pursue a political career. Don't take things like this in a small way and fight back in a half-hearted manner (without even disclosing the specifics of what/who you are talking about). Start with something small but meaningful. Show that you are different from your action. The big buzzwords like transparency, accountability and impunity are reflected in small acts of seeing redress to issue like this. Else, how can people trust someone who won't fight for one's own personal dignity in a lawful way. 

People want a leader they can rely on and this is the first chance you have been handed to show you are different and profess what you preach.

I hope you think it through and take appropriate actions.





Thursday, March 9, 2017

Why we are in bigger trouble than we actually realize?


Our society has shown some worrying signs lately. It does have made progress and come a long way in different aspects. However, our society in large is heading towards more troubles. We all are not aware or have not probably thought it thought but the early warning can already be seen in significant proportion. I personally believe we are heading towards major disaster with enough preparation and homework.

Our society has normalized/institutionalized within itself the recipe for crackdown and failure. Some of my observations that lead me to this conclusion  are:

i) We have normalized violence. The use of violence does not bother us as much as it should. Whether it states actor or non-state actors the general response to violence has been less than what we'd aspect from responsive society. We read about the death of fellow countryman and pass on a shallow comment on it. Our society is being less and less concerned with the use of violence as a tool for various gains. It is now widely accepted as "something normal."

ii) Corruption isn't something that bothers us. Most of us know corruption has been institutionalized in various fonts in Nepal. We have accepted it as part of the system. Some even call it "speeding money" to make it sound legit. We have been so used to it that we are no longer offended by the fact corruption around us. We have normalized/institutionalized corruption.

iii) Being unaccountable isn't a big deal. We have seen it in recent time, we are going through a phase where expecting accountability from those exercising authority is not normal. Those in position say and do what pleases them without feeling the need of being accountable for it. Those who are in the position of exercising authority are blinded by the power that they no longer feel the underlying accountability. Being unaccountable isn't something new...its normal.

iv) We have politicized everything aspect of social life that could be politicized. From students to professionals even the religious groups now come in political colors. We have politicized everything that could possibly be politicized and its normal to do so. There is nothing wrong in political lens overriding everything else. Politicizing everything is normal too.

v) We compromise with the quality of everything. From the food we eat to service we receive. We compromise with the quality of everything including our basic necessity education, health, drinking water, clean environment. Our compromise with the quality of everything isn't a bad thing at all. This is how it works and there is nothing we can do about it. Compromising with the quality of everything we need and consume and receive is new normal too.

vi) Not valuing professional competence is normal too. We value our near and dear one, who need the competent when we can replace them with our own. Why bother with all the competence crap when we can do it easy. We prefer easy over right and beneficial over right. So, appointing incompetent over competent is totally normal, provided they pay well for it. Look at the recent instances and you'll understand what I am talking about.

vii) We are draining both labor and brain and are happy with the remittance we receive. It is normal for us that our productive population is working to make other nations great or in some cases GREAT AGAIN. We are not being able to hold onto our youth and that's fine. It's normal for youth to migrant and we are totally fine with it.

As Chris Hedges rightly observed, We now live in a nation where doctors destroy health, lawyers destroy justice, universities destroy knowledge, governments destroy freedom, the press destroys information, religion destroys morals, and our banks destroy the economy. The more alarming concern is that "WE CONSIDER IT NORMAL".

Everything that we have considered normal will have huge impact in our society and we are not even bothered about that.

It is high time to wake up from the "illusion of normalcy".

I sincerely hope that I am wrong about it. I hope our society move on from this without significant bump.


Monday, January 16, 2017

Rest in beats Yama Buddha!!!


A Tribute

I never had an opportunity to know you in person and knew little about you before your tragic death. I knew some of your songs and loved them. After your death (suicide) I heard a lot about you and decided to check available footage of you on youtube. I came across some of the feature news and some interview. I watched some of the interviews and knew more about you as a person. I have shared one of the interviews at the end of the post which I personally was touched by.

Mere interviews are not enough to know a person but it gives the audience a glimpse of who the person is. Turns out you are this guy who was humble, real besides being famous. The way you answer the questions reflects your qualities. 'Never judge a book by its cover' was the quote I was thinking of when I was hearing your interview. We will never know why you did what you did. It is very tragic that you decided to end your life, the life which was already inspirational to many and could have been larger than most can dream of. It is clear from your interview that you were not after money or fame but wanted happiness. I feel really sad that you could not find what you were looking for and now wish that you'd have tried harder or would have looked in right place. (in face of those whom you inspire and entertain with your music).

I hope you rest in your beats.

Yama Buddha (Anil Adhikari) left us and his tragic end has left us with questions as suicide is widespread challenge our generation is facing. The World Health Organization estimates that over 800,000 people die by suicide each year – that’s one person every 40 seconds. Up to 25 times as many again make a suicide attempt. The case of suicide is increasing in Nepal as well. It is high time we start discussing the issue as one of the alarming concern for our societies well being.

We need to connect, communicate and care if we are to combat suicide. Let us work together towards suicide prevention and let people know them that they matter more than they think they do. We need to talk about suicide and create awareness in the underlying cause or at least we need to explain to everyone that suicide is not the ANSWER. We must be loud enough to spread the message that "Suicide doesn’t end the chances of life getting worse, it eliminates the possibility of it ever getting any better".

To those who want to express respect and tribute to Yama Buddha, I urge them to work towards suicide awareness and suicide prevention so we'd deal with actual killer. Let's talk about suicide and spread awareness. It is high time we do something about it. #SuicideAwareness #YouAreNotAlone

The link to the interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oG-8IO9va1c

All we can wonder is Why?

The person who completes suicide, dies once. Those left behind live in anguish and despair, trying to relive those terrible moments and understand … Why? – Quote by Clark (2001) with minor modifications. 

Sunday, January 8, 2017

Does it end here? Is decision against Mr. Lokman Singh Karki an end in itself?



The Context

The Supreme Court of Nepal on Sunday (*8th January 2017) adjudicated that, Lok Man Singh Karki did not meet qualifications required to hold the position of the Chief of the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority (CIAA). The decision immediately removes Mr. Karki from the position of head of the anti-corruption constitutional body of Nepal.

The Positive

i) The Supreme Court gave a landmark judgment is much controversial writ petition. This judgment is a reminder that no-one (even the head of constitutional body) is above the law. This case had its twist and turns from despatching notice to in court defamation attempt. However, at the end, this case gave the positive decision and upheld the rule of law. This decision has been applauded by many and obviously will further public trust in the judiciary.

ii) The applicant Advocate Om Prakash Aryal has been exemplary figure and has reaffirmed that lawyers are not merely "hired guns". They can play constructive role rectify what has gone wrong and restore rule of law. He deserves big appreciation for his persistence, handwork, and professionalism.

iii) The role of justices of the Supreme Court has been very praiseworthy in this case. The Court took its time but did the rights thing. This Case in days to come will be referred to while discussing the 'independence of judiciary' in Nepal.

The Concerns

i) Now it is settled that Mr. Karki was not eligible to be appointed as head of CIAA. Are those appointing him are in question now? or it is the end of the entire plot? I personally feel that those who had an active role in appointment Mr. Karki have now have an obligation to answer, on what basis was he appointed? Was it an honest mistake and can be rectified with a meaningful apology? or is digging deeper necessary to hold those responsible for "ineligible appointment" accountable?

ii) This case reflects the tendency of appointment culture in Nepal. So, as this appointment fails the rule of law test, how many other appointments might have a similar fate? There are other controversies surrounding the appointment under political influence.

iii) Is this case the starting of accountability questioning or will this be the end in itself as this high profile case is settled now? Will legal fraternity, government, public, and other institution consider this case as a starting point towards accountability and rule of law?

Blessing in disguise for Mr. Karki

As there was ( a high) possibility of Mr. Karki being impeached by the parliament, I consider this decision as "blessing in disguise" of him.

i) Mr. Karki is deemed ineligible to have been appointed as the head of CIAA. It is not his mistakes or doing that removes him from the position. Technically, he did not fail the test, those appointed him are under scrutiny and are responsible for blunder (logically).

ii) Had he been removed via Impeachment procedure it would have been Mr. Karki's doing. He would have been the person responsible for his dismissal from the position of the head of the constitutional body. That is quite some burden to carry with you but to Mr. Karki's rescue, the Supreme Court gave the order. The decision is not a favorable one for Mr. Karki but it has done a huge favor for him.

iii) Further, the Court has saved many politicians who were in shaky position in the question of impeachment of Mr. Karki. They must be the biggest winners here and must have had a sigh of relief that they do not have to take a stand in the matter now.


The Supreme Court and all those involved in the case deserve the appreciation for a landmark judgment. However, I personally feel the decision has raised a new question; How can those appointing an ineligible person in the head of CIAA hold accountable for their doing?
Those appointing Mr. Karki are responsible for what they did ?  or will we be satisfied with the dismissal of Mr. Karki. The appointment of Mr. Karki was "bi-product" not the "cause". We need to identify the cause and address the cause or we will spend our energy dealing with bi-product and never get anywhere. 

Friday, December 9, 2016

Let us make an effort to understand human rights

On the occasion of international human rights day 2017, I felt the urge to pen down some my ideas regarding human rights. These are the basic postulates I believe needs clarity while entering into the discourse of/on human rights.

i) Human Rights is broader/more than international human rights law.

Yes, the value of human rights has been translated into international human rights law. The international human rights law regime is probably most important dynamics/aspect/body of human rights. It has helped in translating the values of human rights into law. In no way, we can negate the role and influence of international human rights law. However, the notion of "human rights" is bigger than "international human rights law".  The values of human rights have been translated in form of rights and have been codified in international and domestic legal instrument but we should not forget the basic idea that "human rights" is more than "international human rights law".  Generally speaking,  human rights is bigger than a legal construct that what can be translated in the legal instrument.

ii) Human Rights is a means to an end, not the end itself.

Most of us consider human rights as an end that we are striving to achieve, as a goal. However, properly assessment of notion of human rights would reveal its true nature, a means to an end. A just society or a peaceful society where all individual could live a dignified life could be an ends (maybe) but not human rights. Human Rights is a means, not an end in itself. Human Rights sets basic values and norms of minimal entitlements to every human being and these basic entitlements should not be deemed as an end. The observance of human rights is the desired criterion of a just and functional society.

iii) Human Rights is work in progress.

The idea of human rights is not a rigid and evolve with the society. The foundational idea of human rights may be same but it tends to grow. Thus the idea of human rights should be seen work in progress. If we look at the development of the human rights we can see the growth of human rights. The substantive aspect of human rights keeps on growing with its root in the idea of human rights. The basic value human rights adhere to remains the same whereas the substantive content and understanding of human rights evolve with the society. Thus, we can argue human rights is work in progress and will keep on evolving.

iv) Human Rights is not an alien concept.

The value human rights reflect is observed in its crude form in various religion and civilization. The present day idea of human rights is the refined form of the ideals that were in our religion and culture from time immemorial. The text of Vedas, Quran, and other religious text embodies the values expressed in the present day as human rights. If we look into our own idea of just society we will realize that concepts and ideas know as human rights is not an alien concept for us.

v) Human Rights rhetoric is not sufficient to translate human rights into practice.

With the translation of human rights into human rights law, the number of human rights instruments is increasing. We have seen the unprecedented growth in human rights rhetoric without its proportionate translation in practice. The states express commitments to ideas of human rights and sign and ratify the documents, however, the human rights observance does not tell us the similar story. Human Rights rhetoric is necessary but without its translation in practice it merely isn't of any use.

There still is a need for understanding human rights. The understanding is where observance of human rights truly gets strength from. When we understand the idea and believe in it, translating the idea into practice gets a lot easier.


Happy International Human Rights Day!!!

Wednesday, November 16, 2016

Movies Law Students Should Watch



As teaching faculty in law school, I often use references to movies in my class. I have a huge appreciation for the things the movie can teach us. At times a good movie can teach you to lot more than the lecture in law school. Though most of the movie's reflection of court procedure, proceedings and technicalities are far from the real court proceeding, they do help us in understanding justice system and other aspect associated with it. I do not argue that 'movies' should be primary learning reference but movies definitely can teach you a lot.

I have often been asked about the movies I'd personally recommend for law students or anyone in the legal field and I tend to name few movies that strike my mind at that point. I have decided to list out my recommended movies for law students along with its short description (available in imdb.com) of the movie. The trailer of the movies is also included as this will give the general idea of if you want to watch the movie.

I have listed 26 movies that I have seen. I am sure that I have missed out on other movies. The list of movies is based on my choice of movies and my idea of its relevance to law students. The list is arranged in alphabetical order.

Please feel free to add your favorite movie to the list and do let me know about the movies I have missed out.

     i.         12 Angry Men
A jury holdout attempts to prevent a miscarriage of justice by forcing his colleagues to reconsider the evidence.


   ii.         Anatomy of a Murder
In a murder trial, the defendant says he suffered temporary insanity after the victim raped his wife. What is the truth, and will he win his case?


 iii.         Class Action
Jed Ward is an attorney who specializes in whistleblower, David vs. Goliath, type cases. He finds a client who is suing an auto company over a safety problem that has had a severe effect on his life after the accident. He must replace the current attorney and be ready for trial quickly, and then he finds that the defense attorney will be his estranged daughter.


iv.         Disclosure
A computer specialist is sued for sexual harassment by a former lover turned boss who initiated the act forcefully, which threatens both his career and his personal life.


  v.         Erin Brockovich
An unemployed single mother becomes a legal assistant and almost single-handedly brings down a California power company accused of polluting a city's water supply.


vi.         Find me Guilty
Based on the true story of Jack DiNorscio, a mobster who defended himself in court for what would be the longest mafia trial in U.S. history.


vii.         Fracture
An attorney, intent on climbing the career ladder toward success, finds an unlikely opponent in a manipulative criminal he is trying to prosecute.


viii.         In the Name of the father
A man's coerced confession to an IRA bombing he did not commit results in the imprisonment of his father as well. An English lawyer fights to free them.


ix.         Jolly LL.B
A small time lawyer files a PIL in court against his own idols case.


  x.         Judgment at Nuremberg
In 1948, an American court in occupied Germany tries four Nazi judges for war crimes.


xi.         Law Abiding Citizen
A frustrated man decides to take justice into his own hands after a plea bargain sets one of his family's killers free. He targets not only the killer but also the district attorney and others involved in the deal.


xii.         Michael Clayton
A law firm brings in its "fixer" to remedy the situation after a lawyer has a breakdown while representing a chemical company that he knows is guilty in a multi-billion dollar class action suit.


xiii.         My cousin Vinny
Two New Yorkers are accused of murder in rural Alabama while on their way back to college, and one of their cousins--an inexperienced, loudmouth lawyer not accustomed to Southern rules and manners--comes in to defend them.


xiv.         No One killed Jessica
A journalist, who is more of an activist team up with the sister of a murdered model, as she gets interested in the case and wants to bring justice to her case.


xv.         North Country
A fictionalized account of the first major successful sexual harassment case in the United States -- Jenson vs. Eveleth Mines, where a woman who endured a range of abuse while working as a miner filed and won the landmark 1984 lawsuit.


xvi.         Philadelphia
When a man with AIDS is fired by his law firm because of his condition, he hires a homophobic small time lawyer as the only willing advocate for a wrongful dismissal suit.


xvii.         Pink
When three young women are implicated in a crime; a retired lawyer steps forward to help them clear their names.


xviii.         Provoked: A True Story
It's the true story of a Punjabi woman named Kiranjit Ahluwalia who leaves India to marry a London-based guy, only to be badly abused. She ends up in prison for murdering her abusive husband.


xix.         Shahid
The account of Human Rights lawyer Shahid Azmi, an ordinary citizen with an extraordinary commitment to justice.


xx.         Talvar
An experienced investigator confronts several conflicting theories about the perpetrators of a violent double homicide.

xxi.         The Insider
A research chemist comes under personal and professional attack when he decides to appear in a "60 Minutes" expose on Big Tobacco.


xxii.         The Pelican Brief
A law student uncovers a conspiracy, putting herself and others in danger.


xxiii.         The People vs. Larry Flynt
A partially idealized film of the controversial pornography publisher and how he became a defender of free speech for all people.


xxiv.         The Rainmaker
An underdog lawyer takes on a fraudulent Insurance company.


xxv.         The verdict
A lawyer sees the chance to salvage his career and self-respect by taking a medical malpractice case to trial rather than settling.


xxvi.         To kill a mockingbird
Atticus Finch, a lawyer in the Depression-era South, defends a black man against an undeserved rape charge, and his children against prejudice. 



A good movie can teach you more than same duration lecture.

Enjoy the movies :) 


Saturday, November 5, 2016

Nepal Tops South Asian Rule of Law Index



The recent findings of World Justice Project Rule of Law Index 2016 present us with encouraging findings. Among the South Asian countries Nepal ranks first in rule of law index. Which means, the observance of rule of law in Nepal ranks top among the South Asian countries. Nepal ranks 63rd among 113 countries with an overall score of 0.52. This rule of law index and ranking is based on consideration of Constraints on Government Powers, Fundamental Rights, Civil Justice, Civil Justice, Order and Security, Criminal Justice, Open Government, and Regulatory Enforcement. Nepal’s ranking with the overall score of 0.52 despite being in the low-income group can be considered positive despite the fact that Nepal ranked 48th among 102 Countries in 2015 with an overall score of 0.53.

The concept of rule of law as it reflects the overarching principle that demands the fair and just administration of the law as a minimal requirement. The World Justice Project has derived its definition of rule of law from internationally accepted standards, the World Justice Project’s definition which includes accountability under law, just legislation, effective and efficient implementation of the legislative provision, and delivery of justice in a timely manner by an independent judiciary. Hence, the concept of rule of law encompasses the totality of a fair and just process from legislation to enforcement of judgments. The adherence to rule of law is primary requisite for peace, justice, and equality.

The track record of Nepal in justice and human rights commitment is not very encouraging. The government of Nepal is criticized at home and abroad regularly for its failure to comply with human rights obligations. In this context, findings from the rule of law index give hope in terms of the role of judiciary towards the compliance with rule of law. The findings this shows Nepal need do improve on the issue of corruption and civil justice.

The judiciary and other stakeholders must analyze the findings of the world justice project and look into the ways to improve the existing concerns. This shall help our judiciary become more effective and efficient. This sort of studies is very important and is expected to be conducted on regular basis. However, our legal academia has failed us in research activities to diagnose the concerns and analyze the context. The study conducted by World Justice Project should initiate academic discourse in Nepal country findings so the rule of law observation would be the basic norm.

There have been various concerns relating to the performance of judiciary and corruption within the judiciary. On the basis of study reports specific recommendation and plans can be formulated to strengthen the judicial institution of Nepal as we are presented with the information we are in dire need of. Further, those working hard in Judiciary needs to be applauded for the observance of rule of law and needs to reminded that we still have a long way to go.

The findings from the report should not be exaggerated but it can be taken as a positive indication towards Nepal’s commitment towards rule of law. We obviously have substantive issues on hand to deal with that would determine nation's compliance with the human rights and rule of law standard in days to come. However, we need to take positive message regarding our judiciary, the legal framework, and commitment towards the value of rule of law.

It must be understood that the report is specific to rule of law index and is does not reflect the performance index of the judiciary. However, the in-depth analysis of the findings offers insightful information for the areas that needs reform for the effective judiciary. In absence of specific research on the matter in domestic academia, the judiciary needs to refer to this study and identify the areas of improvement.